The Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA), known for backing policies that protect online users while upholding constitutional rights, has voiced concerns regarding proposed legislation in California. The association contends that three bills under consideration—AB 56, AB 853, and AB 1064—pose a threat to free expression, user privacy, and digital innovation.
AB 56 mandates social media platforms to implement a warning label and enforce a 90-second delay after users exceed a set time limit. According to CCIA, this requirement raises First Amendment concerns and could unduly restrict digital access for communities reliant on these platforms. The bill's wide definition of “social media platform” and the necessity for time-tracking may impose significant compliance costs on smaller entities.
AB 853 calls for major online platforms and device makers to integrate technology that labels and monitors digital content. While CCIA acknowledges the significance of transparency and combating misinformation, it argues that this bill may disrupt the deliberate development of these technological tools. The association warns that early adoption could lead to increased user costs, slowed innovation, and privacy infringement due to potential sharing of personal information.
AB 1064, targeting AI developers with tools accessible to minors, is criticized for its vague definitions that could complicate compliance and result in legal challenges. The bill proposes a public registry potentially necessitating the divulgence of sensitive information, and enforcement mechanisms involving fines that may encourage stringent regulation.
Aodhan Downey, CCIA's State Policy Manager, issued a statement expressing the association's stance: “We support smart, thoughtful policy that helps keep kids safe online – but these proposals fall short of that goal. Each bill introduces broad, poorly defined requirements that could backfire by chilling speech, discouraging innovation, and reducing access to online services for families and communities across California. Lawmakers should focus on workable, targeted solutions that promote digital safety without creating new risks for users and small businesses.”